Butter Shops

What is the Best Organic Peanut Butter?

What is the best organic peanut butter

Share This Post

Welcome to your go-to guide for finding the best organic peanut butter! Many people love peanut butter. More are now choosing organic options.

But there are so many choices. Picking the right organic peanut butter can be overwhelming. That’s where we step in.

In this article, we’ll break down what makes peanut butter “organic” and talk about why it’s a popular choice. We’ll also give you easy tips on what to look for when shopping for organic peanut butter.

We’ll cover what ingredients to check for and how to pick the right texture for you.

Then, we’ll dive into some of the best organic peanut butter brands out there. We’ll tell you what makes each one special and help you figure out which might be the best fit for you.

But we’re not stopping there! We’ll also share some fun and tasty ways to enjoy your organic peanut butter beyond spreading it on bread.

Get ready for some yummy recipes and creative ideas to make the most of your organic peanut butter.

So, if you’re ready to upgrade your peanut butter game and find the perfect organic option, let’s start!

What Makes Peanut Butter “Organic”?

What is the best organic peanut butter (2)

On a jar of peanut butter, ‘organic’ means the peanuts used to make it were grown without fake pesticides or fertilizers.

Instead, organic farmers use natural methods to protect their crops. These methods can be better for the environment and for your health too.

Choosing organic peanut butter means you’re avoiding extra chemicals in your food. Some people believe these chemicals can have long-term benefits for your well-being. 

But, it’s important to remember that organic options may cost more. They are also less available than non-organic ones.

In short, peanuts make “organic” peanut butter. Farmers grow them without synthetic chemicals. It gives peanut butter lovers a more natural and healthy option.

What to Look for in an Organic Peanut Butter

When you’re on the hunt for the perfect organic peanut butter, here are some key things to keep an eye out for:

What is the Best Organic Peanut Butter


  • Opt for simplicity: Look for organic roasted peanuts listed as the main ingredient, with salt as optional.
  • Avoid the bad stuff: Stay away from added sugars, hydrogenated oils, preservatives, and palm oil. These extras can mess with the natural goodness of your peanut butter.


  • Choose your texture: Decide if you prefer creamy or crunchy peanut butter. It’s all about personal preference!
  • Some brands offer convenient options. They have dripless or no-stir varieties. These make your peanut butter experience mess-free and easy.

Dietary Needs:

  • There are sugar and salt-free options. If you’re watching your sugar or salt intake, there are peanut butter options without these additives.
  • Allergy-friendly choices: For those with peanut allergies, explore peanut-free alternatives. Also, consider peanut butter with added healthy fats. For example, chia seeds or flax seeds add extra nutrition.

Flavor Profile:

  • Roasting matters: Light roast or dark roast? The roasting process affects the flavor of your peanut butter, so choose according to your taste preferences.
  • Watch out for sweeteners: Flavored organic peanut butter options like cocoa or honey can be tasty, but be cautious of added sugars. Always check the ingredients list.

Brand and Certification:

  • Trustworthy brands: Stick to reputable brands with USDA organic certification. This ensures that your peanut butter meets certain quality standards.
  • Ethical considerations are key. If you’re passionate about ethical sourcing, look for fair-trade options. They support farmers and communities.

Popular Organic Peanut Butter Brands

Briefly review 3-5 popular organic peanut butter brands, highlighting their key features:

  • Brand name
  • Ingredients
  • Texture (creamy/crunchy)
  • Additional considerations (sweeteners, salt, certifications)
  • Include a shortlist of pros and cons for each brand (consider including a rating system if comfortable).

are some of the top contenders in the organic peanut butter space:

  1. Smucker’s Organic Peanut Butter


What is the Best Organic Peanut Butter


  • A popular and widely available brand with USDA organic certification.
  • Offers both creamy and crunchy varieties.
  • Simple ingredients: organic roasted peanuts and salt (optional).
  • Affordable option.

Pros: Affordable, readily available, good source of protein and healthy fats. 

Cons: May lack the complex flavor of some other brands, and some varieties contain added sugar.

  1. Justin’s Organic Peanut Butter

What is the Best Organic Peanut Butter

  • Known for using high-quality ingredients and single-serving packets for convenience.
  • USDA-certified organic and uses dry roasted peanuts.
  • It is available in creamy and crunchy textures. It also comes in flavored varieties. But, be mindful of added sugar in flavored options.

Pros: High-quality ingredients, convenient single-serving packets, good source of protein and healthy fats. 

Cons: More expensive than some other brands, flavored varieties may contain added sugar.

  1. Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter

What is the Best Organic Peanut Butter

  • It is a classic brand. It focuses on simple, all-natural ingredients. It isn’t certified organic but uses organic practices.
  • Offers both creamy and crunchy peanut butter.
  • Contains roasted peanuts and salt.
  • Known for its smooth texture (especially the creamy variety).

Pros: Simple, all-natural ingredients, smooth texture, good source of protein and healthy fats. 

Cons: Not USDA-certified organic, may not be as available as some other brands.

  1. Peanut Butter & Co. Organic Peanut Butter

What is the Best Organic Peanut Butter

  • It offers many organic peanut butter options. These include creamy, crunchy, and dripless types.
  • USDA-certified organic and uses a variety of roasting styles (dark roast for a deeper flavor).
  • Some varieties include healthy add-ins like chia seeds or flax seeds.

Pros: There are many textures and options. It is USDA-certified organic. It has protein, healthy fats, and fiber. This is especially true if you add nuts and seeds. 

Cons: Can be more expensive than some other brands, some varieties may contain added sugar.

  1. Trader Joe’s Organic Creamy Peanut Butter

What is the Best Organic Peanut Butter

  • A budget-friendly option from the popular grocery store chain Trader Joe’s.
  • USDA-certified organic and uses just roasted peanuts and salt.
  • Known for its creamy texture and good value.

Pros: It’s affordable and USDA-certified organic. It has simple ingredients. Also, it’s a good source of protein and healthy fats. 

Cons: Only available at Trader Joe’s locations, and may not be as widely available as other brands.

Remember, this is not a full list. There are many other great organic peanut butter brands. When choosing an organic peanut butter, consider your individual preferences and dietary needs.

How to Enjoy Your Organic Peanut Butter

Organic peanut butter isn’t just for sandwiches! Here are some fun ways to enjoy it:

Classic Uses:

  • Sandwiches: Spread creamy or crunchy organic peanut butter on whole-wheat bread for a yummy snack.
  • Fruit & Veggie Dipper: Dip apple slices, celery sticks, or banana slices in organic peanut butter for a healthy treat.

Creative Ideas:

  • Smoothies: Add a spoonful of creamy peanut butter to your morning smoothie for a tasty protein boost.
  • Homemade Peanut Butter Cups: Make your peanut butter cups using organic peanut butter and dark chocolate for a healthier dessert.
  • Energy Bites: Mix oats, dried fruit, honey, and organic peanut butter for quick and nutritious snacks.
  • Peanut Butter Sauce: Mix peanut butter with soy sauce, vinegar, and sriracha for a flavorful sauce for noodles.
  • Peanut Butter Yogurt Parfait: Layer yogurt, granola, and organic peanut butter for a delicious breakfast or snack.
  • Baked Goods: Use organic peanut butter in cookies or muffins for a nutty twist.

Easy Recipes:

  • Simple Peanut Butter Oatmeal:
      • Cook oats in milk and water until tender.
      • Stir in organic peanut butter for a creamy finish.
      • Top with sliced banana or nuts for extra flavor.
  • No-Bake Peanut Butter Energy Bites:
    • Mix oats, nuts/seeds, dried fruit, peanut butter, and honey.
    • Roll into balls and chill until firm.

Storage Tips for Freshness:

  • Keep organic peanut butter in a cool, dark place like your pantry.
  • Stir well before using to blend the natural oils.
  • Refrigerate to preserve freshness, but let it soften at room temperature before spreading.

Enjoy these organic peanut butter ideas and have fun getting creative with this tasty spread!

Bottom Line

Organic peanut butter is a versatile and delicious addition to your diet. Whether you prefer it on a sandwich, in a smoothie, or as a dip for fruits and veggies, organic peanut butter offers a healthy source of protein and fats.

Key Tips:

  • Variety: Experiment with different textures like creamy or crunchy.
  • Recipes: Try making energy bites, and peanut butter cups, or adding it to oatmeal.
  • Storage: Keep it in a cool, dark place and stir well before using.

Get creative and enjoy the wholesome goodness of organic peanut butter in your favorite recipes and snacks!

Frequently asked questions

Q: Is organic peanut butter healthier than regular peanut butter?

A: Organic peanut butter generally avoids synthetic pesticides, fertilizers, and preservatives that may be present in conventional peanut butter.

Additionally, organic varieties often have a simpler ingredient list, free from added sugars, hydrogenated oils, and unhealthy fats.  However,  focusing on ingredients and nutrition facts is important regardless of the “organic” label.

Q: Does organic peanut butter need to be refrigerated?

A:  No, unopened organic peanut butter can be stored in a cool, dark place like your pantry. Once opened, refrigeration can help extend shelf life and solidify the peanut butter, especially creamy varieties.

However, it may become slightly stiffer. You can take the jar out of the fridge for a few minutes before using it to soften it up.

Q: What’s the difference between creamy and crunchy peanut butter?

A: It all comes down to the grinding process. Creamy peanut butter is made from finely ground peanuts, while crunchy peanut butter has some larger peanut pieces mixed in for texture.

Q:  I see “natural” peanut butter on the shelf.  Is that the same as organic?

A: Not necessarily. “Natural” typically refers to the absence of artificial ingredients or preservatives. While some natural peanut butter may be made with organically grown peanuts, they may not be USDA-certified organic. Always check the label for details.

Q: I have a peanut allergy. Are there any safe alternatives?

A: Unfortunately, for those with peanut allergies,  avoiding all peanut products is essential. There are many delicious nut and seed butter alternatives available, such as almond butter, sunflower seed butter, or cashew butter. Be sure to check labels carefully to avoid any hidden peanut ingredients.

Q:  Where can I find good deals on organic peanut butter?

A: Prices can vary depending on the brand and ingredients. Look for store brands or generic organic peanut butter, which often offer good value.  Warehouse clubs like Costco or Sam’s Club may also offer larger quantities at a discounted price.

Q:  How can I tell if a peanut butter brand is reputable?

A: Look for the USDA organic certification seal on the label. This ensures the peanuts were grown according to strict organic standards. You can also research brands online to learn more about their sourcing practices and commitment to quality.

Leave a Comment

More To Explore

reeses peanut butter recipe

Easy and quick reeses peanut butter recipe

HOMEMADE REESES PEANUT BUTTER While you can’t replicate the exact Reese’s peanut butter cup experience at home due to proprietary ingredients, here are two recipe options inspired by Reese’s that you might enjoy: Peanut Butter Recipe Ingredients  For the Peanut Butter Filling: ¾ cup crushed graham crackers (adds a textural contrast) 1 cup powdered sugar

whipped peanut butter recipe

The best whipped peanut butter recipe

whipped peanut butter recipe This recipe creates a light and airy peanut butter spread, perfect for topping fruit, yogurt, or using as a dip Ingredients  ¼ cup cold heavy whipping cream (essential for whipping) 1 tablespoon smooth peanut butter (not crunchy or natural) 1 tablespoon powdered sugar (for sweetness) ½ teaspoon vanilla extract (for flavor)